Modesty: a beautiful picture of God’s grace
Beautiful in His Time is a participant in multiple affiliate marketing programs.Ā The author of this blog may receive commission for purchases or clicks made through links on this website.
This post is part 11 in a blog series that I have entitledĀ “the wilderness between legalism and grace,”Ā in which I shareĀ how I came to realize that I had an incorrect view of God and self and how I became free of the system of legalism whereby I was trying to earn God’s favor.Ā You can view all of the posts in the seriesĀ here onĀ the series landing page. This post is about the touchy subject of modesty.
_____
During the second semester of my sophomore year (at College #3), someone had the crazy idea to switch identities with girls for the day, just for kicks. Several girls participated in the activity, I being one of them (although if I remember correctly, it took a lot of coaxing from my new friends).
We girls helped make up our identity-double in the way that we chose – with our hairstyle, clothes, jewelry, and style of applying makeup. The results were astonishing.
This was a normal college day look for me:
By the time my double got through with me, I looked like this:
I squirmed self-consciously through my morning classes and chapel, where the administrators laughed off the harmless antics of college girls and a friend told me that she overheard one of the guys say that I was “hot.”
After chapel I made a bee-line for my dorm room, wiped off the makeup and changed into something more…me. More conservative. More modest.
_____
That afternoon I got online and shared the photos with my forum friends, writing a long explanation of how girls focus so much on the external appearance and how we need to focus on inner beauty – or something spiritual sounding like that.
I had been uncomfortable, self-conscious.
I felt “worldly” – I thought my outfit was “form-fitting” and that my face looked fake.
And knowing that a guy had noticed me for something other than my brains and “natural beauty” made me the most uncomfortable.
Guilt. Shame.
_____
I look back and sort of shake my head in bewilderment. I see my full-length picture and see that my thin body that barely had the slightest curve was still covered, still modest. My hair still shined in the light. My eyes still popped with my smile.
Certainly, the two styles are drastically different. And if you’ve seen even recent pictures of me, you’ll notice that I still prefer more “natural” makeup and favor curly hair.
It’s definitely true (and sadly so) that so often inner beauty is ridiculed, and young girls are taught to focus on the outward appearance at all costs.
But an over-emphasis on modesty draws attention to the female body in a different way. It is objectified, not as something to be lusted after, but as something to be feared and ashamed of. The outward appearance is still focused on, just in a different way.
From the time I was a little girl I had an inflated view of modesty that didn’t come from my parents or even the churches I attended. Sleeveless tops made me uncomfortable, and I always wore shorts over my swimsuit. Then in high school when I started attending a legalistic church where modesty was stressed even more, my personal standards got stricter and stricter.
Modesty is most definitely important, and most definitely a Biblical concept – that much I will not ever dispute.
The beautiful, naked human body was not originally designed to be covered. But sin perverted nakedness and made us ashamed of our bodies.
“And the eyes of them both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig leaves together, and made themselves aprons.Ā And he said, I heard thy voice in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself.” (Genesis 3:7, 10)
Even our best attempts at modesty – a modesty based in fear and shame – failed before the holiness of God.
So God called us out of shame and gave us coverings. Coverings of sacrifice. Coverings of grace. <—tweet this!
Coverings that said, “Your attempts at goodness and modesty will never be enough. You need my goodness that only comes through the sacrifice of an innocent.”
“Unto Adam also and to his wife did theĀ LordĀ God make coats of skins, and clothed them.” Genesis 3:21
But now, Christianity still so often promotes a system of modesty that is based in shame. We feebly and fearfully adopt “standards” and try to cover up our sin, our shame, with our own inflated sense of goodness – a goodness that can never be good enough.
Our goodness can never cover our shame. Only God’s grace can. <—tweet this!
What if, instead of dressing out of a sinful desire to gain the attention of men, or out of an inflated sense of our own goodness (“modesty”) motivated by the fear caused by our shame, we instead approached modesty with this attitude:
God, you see me in all of my nakedness, nakedness that you created to be beautiful but was perverted because of my sin. You see me in all of my sinfulness. I can never be good enough, “modest” enough to cover my sin and shame. But you love me and gave me grace. May what I wear today be a picture of the sacrificial covering of your grace – grace that is greater than my sin and shame. Grace that reflects your love and beauty.
This modesty is humble, reverent, and truly “shamefaced.” It doesn’t judge others who don’t dress “as modestly as” you do, because it recognizes the frailty of attempting to cover nakedness with goodness. This modesty focuses on Christ’s goodness, not our own.
This modesty is a picture of grace.
When modesty is addressed in the New Testament, it is done so with a focus on reverence for God:
The Bible never says, “Dress modestly, or men will lust after you” (fear-based) or “Dress modestly because you can’t come to me in your nakedness” (shame-based).
Rather, it says this:
“Whose adorning let it not be that outward adorning of plaiting the hair, and of wearing of gold, or of putting on of apparel; But let it be the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price.”
Regardless of whether or not I wear a sleeveless dress, straighten my hair in a “modern” style, wear eyeliner, or some guy thinks I’m “hot” – these things don’t define (or not define) me as a “modest” person.
True modesty comes from within.
God wants my heart – not my hair.
He wants my spirit – not my jewelry, makeup, or lack thereof.
He desires a relationship with me in all of my feminine beauty. He looks within.
When {my modesty} fades
All is stripped away
And I simply come
Longing just to bringĀ
Something that’s of worthĀ
That will bless your heart
I’ll bring You more than {my modesty}
For {modesty} in itself
Is not what You have required
You search much deeper within
Through the ways things appear
You’re looking into my heart
I’m coming back to the heart of {modesty}
And it’s all about You
It’s all about You, Jesus
~Heart of Worship by Matt Redman~
_____
Modesty. It’s a touchy subject. Have you fallen prey to a system of modesty that is based in fear and shame and focuses on your own frail attempts at goodness? Have you ever thought about how modesty is a picture of Christ’s sacrificial grace? I’d love to hear from you!Ā
_____
To view all the posts in this blog series, visitĀ the landing page.
Next post, part 12:Ā Disconnect: when God just doesnāt seem relevant
37 Comments
jeanniere
good article
Erin
Found your blog via your comment on Kelly’s modesty post at “Imperfect Homemaking”. Appreciated the heart you shared in this post and your heart for the real purpose of modesty.
Aprille
Thank you Erin for stopping by!
Elisa
I love this series and the lessons you capture in it. Thank you for linking up at More to Be for Transformed Tuesdays. I look forward to reading more!
Aprille
Thanks for hosting!!!
Anonymous
Beautiful post! I find the most important trait that a woman can posses is self confidence and a lot of the shame and fear focused messages on modesty and other subjects in church when I grew up created some very insecure girls who in turn became the very opposite of modest in a quest for attention and acceptance.
Pingback:
Pingback:
apronstringsotherthings
Thank you for sharing your heart on this topic. Your words come across in a clear and loving manner. It really is an issue of the heart, isn’t it? Isn’t all of our life an issue of the heart with God? I touched just a bit on this modest/clothing in my own recent post about thoughts from the book The Hidden Art of Homemaking.
I appreciate what you said: “From the time I was a little girl I had an inflated view of modesty” – interesting how we put just burdensome boundaries on ourselves, thinking they are from God.
stopping by from Fellowship Fridays
Aprille
Thank you so much for your comment! It’s good to know that I come across as clear and loving because it’s a hard balance to find sometimes!
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Amy Beth
I’ve grappled with the modesty issue for a while – being someone who at once craves modesty and doesn’t like feeling exposed (not even for entirely holy reasons either, but partly because of self-consciousness about my body) . . . but also someone who loves fashion. In the end, this was what I come with as my standard for modesty: http://www.modernishhomemaker.com/2013/05/what-does-modesty-mean-wrapping-up.html
Aprille
Thanks for posting. I read through your entire series and feel that you have a very balanced approach to the whole modesty issue!
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Anna Ferrar
“. . .an over-emphasis on modesty draws attention to the female body in a different way. It is objectified, not as something to be lusted after, but as something to be feared and ashamed of. The outward appearance is still focused on, just in a different way.”
^ one of the best things I’ve ever read.
Here’s my two cents:
I’m pro modesty. I ardently believe in covering up the sensual parts of our body. Even so, I’m pretty sick of Christians bashing women like we have some of kind of problem (our body) that needs to be fixed (with covering up every inch) because quite frankly, God made us this way, made us with these bodies. We can only hide so much. We’re women.
Frankly, we’re human beings and God gave us these beautiful bodies (both male and female) for a reason and though I believe in chaste dressing, I think people need to take a break and focus on other aspects of godly living rather than the constant “is lip gloss provocative” or “is layering low cut tops seducing” ect mumbo jumbo.
In short, another excellent article. Thank you. š
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Pingback:
Richard Esther
Wonderful! just what we need in this generation. Thanks, & God bless you
Pingback: